Blog Journal

The "Gift of a Lifetime?"

In the December 8 issue of Business Week, Marc Roth writes:

" . . . if you are planning on being a homeowner now and/or in the foreseeable future, or if you are looking to move your family into a bigger home, then pay more attention to the interest rates than the price of the home. If you have a steady job, good credit, and the down payment, then you really are being offered the gift of a lifetime."

He builds his argument by pointing out that: " . . . rates are so well below historic averages that it should make all current and prospective homeowners take notice of this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity."

He contends that ". . . if you don't act soon, you will regret it.”

To illustrate his contention, he uses a graph found on Mortgage-X.com to point out that today's average 30-year fixed-rate loan with no points or fees -- of about 5% -- is the lowest the rate has been in nearly 40 years.

“In fact, rates are so well below historic averages that it should make all current and prospective homeowners take notice of this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

And it is exactly that, based on what the graph shows us. Let's look at the point on the far left."

In 1970 the rate was approximately 7.25%. After hovering there for a couple of years, it began a trend upward, landing near 10% in late 1973. It settled at 8.5% to 9% from 1974 to the end of 1976. After the rise to 10%, that probably seemed O.K. to most home buyers.

But they weren't happy soon thereafter. From 1977 to 1981, a period of only 60 months, the 30-year fixed rate climbed to 18%.

And when rates started to decline after that, they took a long time to recede to previous levels. They hit 9% for a brief time in 1986 and bounced around 10% to 11% until 1990. For the next 11 years through 2001, the rates slowly ebbed and flowed downward, ranging from 7% to 9%. We've since spent the last nine years, until very recently, at 6% to 7%. So you can see why 5% is so remarkable.

Lessons to learn from these historical trends and numbers

1. “Rates have far further to move upward than downward; for more than 30 years, 7% was the low and 18% the high. The norm was 9% in the 1970s, 10% in the mid-1980s through the early 1990s, 7% to 8% for much of the 1990s, and 6% only over the last handful of years.

2. The last time the long-term trends reversed from low to high, it took more than 20 years (1970 to 1992) for the rate to get back to where it was, and 30 years to actually start trending below the 1970 low.

3. The most important lesson is to understand the actual financial impact the rate has on the cost of purchasing and paying off a home.

Loan Costs

Every quarter-point change in interest rates is equivalent to approximately $6,000 for every $100,000 borrowed over the course of a 30-year fixed. While different in each region, for the sake of simplicity, let's assume that the average person is putting $40,000 down and borrowing $200,000 to pay the price of a typical home nationwide.

Thus, over the course of the life of the loan, each quarter-point move up in interest rates will cost that buyer $12,000 . . .

We are at 5%. As you can see by the graph above, as the economy stabilizes, it is reasonable for us to see 30-year fixed rates climb to 6% within the foreseeable future and probably to a range of 7% to 8% when the economy is humming again. If every quarter of a point is worth $12,000 per $200,000 borrowed, then each point is worth almost $50,000.

The Risk in Not Acting Now

Roth guesses that

“even though home prices have steadied, you may be thinking you can get another $5,000 or $10,000 discount if you wait (never mind the $8,500 or $6,500 tax credit due to run out next spring). Or you may be waiting for the news to tell you the economy is ‘more stable’ and it's safe to get back in the pool.”

Contrary to this reasoning, he suggests:

“In exchange for what you may think is prudence, you will risk paying $50,000 more per point in interest rate changes between now and the time you decide you are ready to buy. And you are ignoring the fact that according to the Case-Shiller index, home prices in most regions have been trending back up for the last several months.”

He concludes:

“What I'm trying to impress upon everyone is that if you are planning on being a homeowner now and/or in the foreseeable future, or if you are looking to move your family into a bigger home, then pay more attention to the interest rates than the price of the home. If you have a steady job, good credit, and the down payment, then you really are being offered the gift of a lifetime.”

Let me know what you think. Do you agree with Roth? Or do you see any holes in his argument.

Best,

Team Diana

_____________

Fair Use

Excerpts of this article and the graph are cited and reprinted under the Fair Use provisions of U.S. copyright law, for their value as news, research, and providing essential information for users of this Web site. These excerpts are presented strictly for their educational purpose. All rights remain with the original authors and publications.